Responsible finance
Greenwashing in funds: what the enforcement cases actually found
Fines against asset managers and a pension fund show what regulators mean by greenwashing: not a fund that is too brown, but a firm that did not do what it said.
"Greenwashing" is often used loosely, as an insult for anything sustainable that someone dislikes. Regulators use it more narrowly: a firm said something about the environmental or social side of its products that was not true, or that it could not show was true. A handful of settled cases now show what that looks like in practice. They are worth reading closely, because none of them turned on whether a fund was "green enough". Each turned on the gap between what a firm told investors and what it actually did.
BNY Mellon: a review that did not always happen
In May 2022 the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) charged BNY Mellon Investment Adviser over statements about environmental, social and governance (ESG) considerations in certain mutual funds. According to the SEC's order, from July 2018 to September 2021 the firm represented or implied that all investments in the funds had undergone an ESG quality review, when numerous holdings had no ESG quality review score at the time they were bought. The firm settled without admitting or denying the findings and paid a $1.5 million penalty (SEC press release 2022-86).
The lesson is simple and recurs in every case below: a process described in a prospectus is a promise. If the process is "every holding is screened", an unscreened holding is a misstatement, whatever its actual merits.
Goldman Sachs Asset Management: procedures written, then not followed
In November 2022 the SEC charged Goldman Sachs Asset Management (GSAM) over two mutual funds and one separately managed account strategy marketed as ESG investments. The order found that from April 2017 until February 2020 GSAM had policies and procedures failures around the ESG research its teams used to pick and monitor securities. For one product, there were no written procedures for ESG research at all until June 2018. Once procedures existed, they required a questionnaire for each company before it entered the portfolio; in practice, many questionnaires were completed after the securities had already been selected. GSAM paid a $4 million penalty, again without admitting or denying the findings.
Nothing in the order says the funds held "bad" companies. The problem was that investors were told about a disciplined research process that was applied out of order, or not at all.
DWS: "ESG in our DNA"
The largest US case so far concerned DWS Investment Management Americas, a subsidiary of Deutsche Bank. In September 2023 the SEC settled two actions with the firm for $25 million in total. One, unrelated to sustainability, concerned anti-money-laundering controls and carried a $6 million penalty. The other concerned ESG and carried a $19 million penalty and a censure.
The SEC's order found that DWS marketed itself as a leader in ESG that followed specific policies for integrating ESG factors into research and investment recommendations, but that from August 2018 until late 2021 it failed to adequately implement certain provisions of its global ESG integration policy. It also failed to adopt policies and procedures designed to make sure its public statements about its ESG-integrated products were accurate. In the words of the SEC's enforcement division, DWS "advertised that ESG was in its 'DNA'", but its investment professionals did not follow the processes it marketed.
The DWS case matters because it concerned "ESG integration", the broadest and vaguest of sustainable investment claims. Integration does not promise any particular outcome; it promises that ESG information is considered. The SEC treated even that modest promise as something a firm must be able to prove.
Mercer: exclusions that did not exclude
Australia produced the first court-imposed penalty. In August 2024 the Federal Court ordered Mercer Superannuation (Australia) to pay A$11.3 million in a case brought by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), its first greenwashing case before that court. Mercer had marketed seven "Sustainable Plus" investment options to members "deeply committed to sustainability", stating that they excluded carbon-intensive fossil fuel companies, alcohol production and gambling. In fact members in those options were invested in companies from each excluded sector: according to ASIC, 15 fossil fuel companies, 15 alcohol producers and 19 gambling companies. Mercer admitted the statements were misleading. The judge described the contraventions as serious and linked them to inadequate systems for checking ESG claims.
Exclusions are the easiest sustainability claim to test: either a company is in the portfolio or it is not. That is precisely why they are dangerous to overstate.
What the cases have in common
- They are about words, not performance. None of the regulators ruled on whether a fund was sustainable in some absolute sense. They compared marketing and disclosure with internal practice.
- Process claims count. "We review every holding", "we integrate ESG", "we exclude X": each is a factual statement that can be checked against records.
- Controls are the weak point. In each case the finding was about missing or unfollowed procedures, or systems that could not catch a holding that contradicted the marketing.
- Penalties are modest relative to the firms. The sums are small for global asset managers. The reputational cost, and the published findings, probably weigh more.
The rules have tightened since
Most of the conduct in these cases dates from 2017 to 2023, before newer rules took effect. Several jurisdictions now regulate the claims themselves, not only the general duty not to mislead. The US, the EU and the UK all have rules on when a fund can use words such as "sustainable", "ESG" or "green" in its name, which we explained in what fund-name rules now require. In the UK, the Financial Conduct Authority's anti-greenwashing rule, in force since May 2024, requires sustainability references to be consistent with the product's characteristics and to be fair, clear and not misleading. In the EU, funds that promote environmental or social characteristics must publish standard annexes, including the share of investments aligned with the EU Taxonomy, which gives investors a fixed place to look.
Questions to ask before trusting an ESG claim
- What exactly is promised? Exclusions, a minimum share of sustainable investments, a rating threshold, or only "integration"? The narrower the promise, the easier it is to check.
- Is it in the legal documents or only in the marketing? A claim made on a web page but absent from the prospectus is a warning sign.
- Can you see the holdings? Most funds publish full or top holdings. If a fund excludes fossil fuels, look for the largest oil, gas and coal companies.
- Whose data drives the screen? If the process relies on an ESG rating, ask which provider, and what happens to companies it does not cover.
- Who checks? Ask whether compliance or an external auditor tests that the process is followed. Our 10-point checklist covers the rest of a manager's policy.
None of this requires expertise in climate science. It requires the habit the regulators showed in every case: reading what a firm says it does, and asking for the evidence that it does it.
Sources
- US Securities and Exchange Commission, press release 2023-194, 25 September 2023, DWS to pay $25 million for anti-money laundering violations and misstatements regarding ESG investments; press release 2022-209, 22 November 2022 (Goldman Sachs Asset Management); press release 2022-86, 23 May 2022 (BNY Mellon Investment Adviser).
- Australian Securities and Investments Commission, media release 24-173MR, ASIC's first greenwashing case results in landmark $11.3 million penalty for Mercer, and Federal Court judgment of 2 August 2024.
Related: fund-name rules · ESG ratings · responsible-investment checklist.